Adopting a Pet vs. An Older Canine: Execs and Cons


Adult and puppy dog

Irina Polonina / Stocksy
Deciding between adopting a pet or an grownup canine is a giant choice that ought to align together with your life-style. Puppies demand extra consideration, time, and coaching in comparison with grownup canines, who are sometimes extra mellow and will already be house-trained. Whereas puppies could also be adaptable to new individuals and conditions, grownup canines provide extra predictable personalities.

In the end, your best option between adopting a pet or an grownup pet depends upon your distinctive circumstances and preferences. Use our easy pet and grownup canine professional/con lists to seek out out which new member of the family may be the perfect match for you.

What are the advantages of getting a pet?

There’s no approach round it: Puppies are rather a lot of labor. On the plus aspect, getting a pet implies that all that point spent coaching creates a robust, irreplaceable bond. Nurturing a pup from the very begin of their life performs an enormous function in shaping their grownup persona, and provides many human caretakers a deep sense of goal. In fact, we’d be remiss to not point out one huge good thing about getting a pet — a pet’s infinite vitality and playful nature, which is usually a nice match for a lot of people and households. Listed here are a number of the execs of adopting a pet as a substitute of adopting an grownup canine.

Constructing bonds

As you spend numerous hours educating your pet to go pee and poop exterior, sit, keep, and heel, you’ll even be working in your relationship. This shared expertise will create a robust bond between you and your pet that may final a lifetime. That’s to not say you may’t bond with an grownup canine, however some canine dad and mom take a particular curiosity in elevating a canine from puppyhood.


The essential socialization interval for a pet spans roughly the primary three to 12 weeks of life. It’s throughout this time that puppies are most open to studying about and experiencing new individuals, locations, and issues. This makes adopting a pet a good selection if you wish to form a social and adaptable companion to your life-style.

An lively companion

Life with a pet is something however boring. If you’re not chasing them round the home (probably as a result of they’ve found one thing they deem chew-worthy), you’ll end up on the park, canine park, or pet social hour, burning off that infamous pet vitality. And being the social butterflies that they’re, puppies are a good way to get entangled in your neighborhood and meet different canine dad and mom. However after a day stuffed with journey, relaxation assured you’ll be rewarded with the sight of an lovely pet curled up — or sprawled out — in a nap.

Higher insurance coverage charges

You’ll wish to think about pet insurance coverage to assist cowl emergency and/or routine medical prices. Enrolling puppies in pet insurance coverage as quickly as they arrive residence with you lets you safe complete protection from the beginning and reduces the probabilities of potential premium will increase as a result of age or pre-existing situations.

puppy destroying stuff

#CNF / Adobe Inventory

What are the cons of adopting a pet?

Whereas there are many execs to adopting a pet as a substitute of an grownup canine, there are some downsides to contemplate. Listed here are the cons of adopting a pet.

Restricted flexibility

As a result of they’ve undeveloped bladders, puppies have to be taken out to alleviate themselves as typically as each half-hour. Even at 5 months, puppies can’t maintain their bladder for greater than three hours at a time. Moreover, puppies have to be fed a number of instances all through the day, typically as much as 4 or 5 instances for toy or small-breed canines vulnerable to hypoglycemia.

Important time dedication for coaching and socialization

Adopting a pet requires a considerable funding of effort and time to make sure they turn out to be well-adjusted and well-behaved members of your family. Coaching and socialization means: housetraining, studying fundamental cues (sit, keep, heel), leash coaching, and socialization with different individuals and animals. Pet dad and mom will have to be constant and affected person and will even must pay for pet kindergarten, a behaviorist, or a coach for a well-rounded strategy.

Numerous cleansing—and chunk marks

Even probably the most diligent housetraining efforts received’t safeguard in opposition to all pet accidents — so make sure you puppy-proof your own home. Potty coaching apart, puppies have growing gastrointestinal programs that could be extra delicate than a completely developed grownup abdomen, says Dr. Renee Schmid, DVM, a senior veterinary toxicologist on the Pet Poison Helpline. This could result in occasional vomiting or diarrhea, particularly in case your pet will get into one thing they shouldn’t. Along with the occasional mess, puppies discover with their mouths and are certain to chew when teething. To discourage chewing behaviors and relieve discomfort, present them with loads of protected chew toys.


Whereas no pet is free and even low-cost, puppies usually incur increased preliminary and lifelong prices in comparison with grownup canines. Adoption charges or breeder charges are typically increased for puppies, and also you’ll must account for veterinary bills for spaying or neutering, microchipping, and vaccinations. That stated, many shelters ship residence puppies neutered/spayed, microchipped, and up-to-date on core pet vaccines. Extra prices might embrace pet care, pet kindergarten lessons, important provides, and common veterinary checkups, which puppies require ceaselessly throughout their first yr of life.

large lavender Chesapeake bay retriever dog

Tanya Consaul Pictures / Shutterstock

What are the advantages of getting an older canine?

The advantages of getting an older canine embrace a probably much less demanding care-and-training regime, permitting you to get pleasure from a extra relaxed companionship. Many grownup canines and seniors have already got fundamental coaching down and might go longer between meals and potty breaks than puppies. In addition they have established personalities and traits, which suggests you may give attention to discovering a canine that aligns together with your preferences and life-style. However above all, selecting to undertake an older canine provides the rewarding alternative to supply a deserving pup with a second likelihood at a joyful life.

What are the professionals and cons of adopting an grownup canine?

Listed here are the professionals and cons of adopting an grownup canine as a substitute of adopting a pet:

  • Fewer coaching and socialization necessities: Older canines typically have a strong basis in fundamental coaching, eliminating the necessity for in depth housetraining and basic coaching lessons. That being stated, ask shelter workers concerning the canine’s behavioral historical past. Rescue canines with a background of trauma or restricted residence dwelling expertise might require extra coaching and socialization, however their wants are typically much less demanding in comparison with puppies.
  • Extra flexibility: Older canines require much less frequent toilet breaks (usually each 4 to 6 hours) and fewer meals a day than puppies, which is a plus in the event you work lengthy hours or have a busy schedule. Needless to say adopting a senior canine might include particular care wants, so make sure you discuss to the shelter workers concerning the pup’s present schedule and current well being situations. 
  • Established persona and traits: Not like puppies, whose personalities are nonetheless growing, older canines have established traits and behaviors. This lets you select a canine that aligns together with your life-style and preferences, whether or not you’re on the lookout for a mellow pup, a canine who will get together with youngsters, or one who tends to not bark a lot. 
  • A second likelihood at a contented life: Adopting an older canine gives them with a loving residence and a second likelihood to expertise the enjoyment of companionship. You’ll be giving a deserving canine the chance to dwell out their remaining years in consolation, safety, and unconditional love. 
  • Reduces pet overpopulation: Moreover, adopting grownup canines helps scale back the overpopulation of pets by lowering the demand for puppies, purebreds, and designer canines. “Many canines find yourself in shelters as a result of irresponsible breeders and unqualified people making an attempt to breed animals for fast revenue, resulting in an extra of undesirable animals,” explains veterinarian Dr. Kevin Puzycki, spokesperson for Stable Gold Pet
  • Value: Adopting an older canine is usually a extra budget-friendly possibility than adopting a pet. Many shelters and rescues provide lowered or waived adoption charges for older canines, releasing up your finances for important provides. Moreover, older canines are sometimes already microchipped, spayed or neutered, and up-to-date on vaccinations, additional decreasing your preliminary bills. Needless to say you’ll nonetheless must take your grownup canine to the veterinarian for normal checkups, which will increase to twice a yr for seniors
  • They’re formed by previous experiences: Not like puppies, grownup canines have already lived via essential durations of their lives. Rescue canines might have skilled neglect, abuse, homelessness, or different unfavourable occasions, which form their personalities and behaviors. Grownup canines can completely adapt to new environments and type sturdy bonds with their caretakers; nevertheless, their previous experiences might require extra persistence, understanding, and specialised coaching.

FAQs (Folks additionally ask):

Is there an age vary for an “grownup” canine?

Typically, small breed canines are thought of puppies all through their first yr of life, whereas massive canines and large breed canines mature extra slowly, usually coming into maturity round 12 to 24 months previous. Upon consumption, shelters search for clues to assist decide a canine’s age. The age at which your native shelter considers a canine to be an grownup, pet, or senior, and due to this fact their adoption charges, might differ.

Are there breed-specific issues when selecting between a pet and an grownup canine?

It’s vital to think about the scale and train wants of a breed when selecting between adopting a pet or an grownup canine. As a result of mixed-breed puppies inherit traits from varied breeds, their grownup measurement and train necessities could be troublesome to foretell. Choosing an grownup canine ensures that their full-grown measurement is a match in your family and that their train wants are a match in your life-style. Puppies, alternatively, might require extra flexibility when it comes to train wants and full-grown measurement.

Is there a value distinction between adopting a pet and an grownup canine?

Adopting a pet typically comes with increased preliminary and lifelong bills in comparison with adopting an grownup canine. When contemplating adopting a pet versus an grownup canine, consider the price of pet lessons, canine walkers, and the price of provides all through your canine’s lifetime. Whereas no pet is free, there are methods to chop pet prices, reminiscent of adopting throughout particular reduced-rate adoption months, buying second-hand provides, and discovering a low-cost vet for important medical care.

Janelle Leeson is a Portland, Oregon-based freelance author. Her work has been featured in magazines reminiscent of Inside Your Canine’s Thoughts, Inside Your Cat’s Thoughts, and Paw Print, as effectively on-line at Insider Opinions, NBC Choose, Store At this time, PetMD, and Each day Paws. She has two journey cats, a flock of city chickens, and a soon-to-be-husband who doesn’t thoughts housing the occasional foster cat — or 5.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *