What If My Canine Responds Solely Once I Have Treats?


A woman wearing jeans and a purple shirt kneels in front of a small black and brown hound dog. The dog is crossing her front paws and looking intently at the treat held in the woman's hand
Instructing Zani to cross her paws utilizing focusing on, shaping, and luring

That is for individuals who have began to coach their canines with meals. First, good for you! Meals is a main reinforcer, canines normally like to work for it, it’s helpful, and also you get loads of bang on your buck!

In case your canine responds solely when you have got meals, nothing is fallacious along with her. Someplace alongside the way in which, she realized some patterns.

Canine Are Nice Predictors

Listed below are three patterns of your conduct your canine could have realized.

  • Should you attempt to do away with your meals lure after utilizing it a few occasions, and she or he doesn’t do the conduct with out the lure, chances are you’ll carry the lure out once more.
  • Even in case you don’t usually lure, if she hesitates after you give her a cue, chances are you’ll contact your deal with pouch, present her the meals, and even give her some.
  • Earlier than any coaching, you collect up some meals, maybe lower up treats, put them in your pocket or pouch, and go to your typical coaching place. Canine says, “Yay! This preparation means I get meals for doing stuff!” You hardly ever use meals outdoors of this situation.

Your intelligent canine has famous these patterns. Someday once you aren’t carrying your deal with pouch and also you haven’t arrange for coaching, you cue her to carry out a conduct. She appears blankly at you and doesn’t transfer. You don’t have any meals to point out her, and she or he continues to remain the place she is.

What occurred?

She isn’t being cussed. She’s not dishonest. You may have unintentionally made “seen meals” or “presence of meals” an antecedent to the conduct. Meals is a part of the cue. So when the meals isn’t there, the cue isn’t full.

You may repair this.

Isn’t a Cue Simply One Factor Like a Phrase or a Hand Sign?

Most cues have extra parts than we notice.

A tan dog with a black tail and ears lies on a purple mat. She is stretching to get a treat a woman is handing her at floor level.
Luring Clara right into a down. It was straightforward as a result of the yoga mat can also be a cue for mendacity down.

What occurs in case you choose up your canine’s bowl or collect up meals toys at a time near once you usually feed her? She will get excited, proper? A meal is coming.

However what in case you choose up the identical bowl or meals toys another time, not near a standard mealtime? She could discover and even pay shut consideration. However she most likely gained’t leap up, able to eat. That’s as a result of, apart from the bowl and meals toys, one other a part of the cue for “mealtime coming” is the time of day.

The issue is that almost all of us don’t notice all of the issues the canine has seen that come collectively to create her cues. And if we unintentionally depart a few of them out, she could not reply. It’s our job both to see that each one the parts are current, or train the canine what’s and isn’t vital. We’re going to do the latter to repair this drawback

A Three-Half Plan

Right here’s how one can repair the “canine doesn’t reply when meals isn’t current” drawback.

It’s worthwhile to present the canine what doesn’t predict meals: your deal with bag or the odor of meals in your pocket, the sight of meals, coaching session preparations, time of day, and so on. And it is advisable present the canine what does predict the chance for meals: your deliberate cue for a conduct. So listed here are the elements of the method.

  1. Clear up coaching mechanics by correctly timing the meals supply and fading lures rapidly.
  2. Present the canine that sure stimuli (e.g. the presence of a deal with pouch) don’t predict reinforcement on their very own. (This course of is known as an extinction trial.)
  3. Make clear the cue. We do that by displaying the canine there’s reinforcement obtainable for performing the conduct after the right cue, irrespective of the opposite situations.

1. Clear Up Your Mechanics

Arrange a digital camera and video your coaching. What are we in search of? Cleansing up mechanics is a giant subject. What we wish is:

  1. Human delivers cue.
  2. Canine does conduct.
  3. Human marks with a clicker or another marker.
  4. Human reaches for meals.
  5. Human provides meals to canine in a technique or one other.
A white dog with a brown ear and some brown speckles is sitting in front of a standing woman. We see the woman only from the waist down. The dog is looking eagerly at her left hand, which is reaching into her pants pocke.
Thanks, Lewis, for telling the world I maintain meals in my left pocket and that I usually attain for it just a bit too early

So once you watch the video of your self, ensure you don’t attain for the meals and even twitch your hand towards the meals till you attain #4. Don’t let your hand drift towards your deal with bag as you say the cue or begin reaching because the canine does the conduct or as you ship your marker. That hand stays nonetheless till after you ship your marker, in case you use one, or till the right conduct is in progress in case you don’t.

Apply with out, then together with your canine till your mechanics are clear.

Luring is one other widespread method meals can turn out to be the fallacious sort of predictor. Should you use a meals lure to get a conduct, it is advisable cease utilizing it very early within the sport. That is referred to as “fading the lure.” Listed below are two glorious movies by Emily Larlham about that.

The next video focuses on fading the lure.

Canine Coaching Tutorial: Fading a Lure (whereas educating SPIN)

This subsequent video is about fading a lure and including a cue. What I actually need you to see are Emily’s glorious mechanics. Watch her proper hand beginning at about 3:00. She retains each her clicker and meals in that hand. See the way it stays inventory nonetheless as she makes use of it to click on, and doesn’t transfer till the canine has completed the conduct.

DEMO of eradicating a LURE and including a VERBAL CUE

Large because of Emily Larlham for having a wonderful video on just about each optimistic reinforcement coaching subject.

2. Break the Prediction with Extinction Trials

For per week or two, a few occasions a day, do what you usually do to arrange for a coaching session, however don’t have one. Lower up meals and put it in your pocket or refill your deal with bag. Then proceed your enterprise for some time. Work at your laptop, do the dishes, work in your yard; do something however practice your canine. Once they come and “ask” you about it, acknowledge them, be candy to them, however don’t give them meals. That is an extinction course of and will be onerous on the learner.

A woman is leaning over a white dog with a brown ear and some brown speckles. She is luring the dog with a treat in her hand and the dog is turning in a circle.
Luring Lewis right into a spin

If there are different indicators you might be about to coach, reminiscent of gathering gear or going to a sure room, you possibly can decouple them too. Your canine has doubtless realized them.

You’re educating your canine that once you work with pet food or carry it round, it means nothing specifically. Meals is background noise. (However you possibly can nonetheless have common coaching periods throughout this time that you simply arrange in your typical method.)

A coach buddy advised me her canines stopped noticing whether or not she had her deal with bag on or off after she turned an expert coach. All of a sudden she was coming and going with the deal with bag on, and it didn’t imply something anymore.

Make your self a schedule for these occasions you’ll put on a deal with bag or do different predictive behaviors. Select completely different occasions of day so the canine doesn’t be taught a sample. (They’re so good at that!)

Most of us would agree {that a} canine who thinks they’re about to have entry to meals, then doesn’t, could really feel the doggie equal of disappointment.

To melt the blow, plan on your first steps to occur when coaching is unlikely, i.e., when there are cues for competing actions. Examples of such occasions could be:

  • proper after you have got completed coaching
  • when about to play together with your canine with a toy (get the toy first, and ensure no meals can fall out of your deal with bag!)
  • when going for a stroll or a trip within the automotive to someplace enjoyable (in case you don’t usually use meals)
  • when preparing for mattress
  • throughout human meals, however provided that you by no means feed your canine from the desk or shortly after

OK, you haven’t fastened the issue, however you’ve laid the groundwork.

3. Meals Can Come from Anyplace

This final important step is a enjoyable train, and is an effective factor to show your canine even in case you don’t have issues with them anticipating to see the meals.

  1. Have some treats in your individual in no matter method is regular for you. Normally, this can be in a pouch or a pocket. Additionally, have among the identical meals in a jar a number of steps away (positioned so the canine can’t assist himself).
  2. Ask your canine for a conduct. After the canine performs the conduct, use a marker in case you usually do (clicker or verbal marker). Step to the jar (rapidly) and reinforce from the treats within the jar. Don’t give your pet food out of your pocket or pouch.
  3. Do this in several elements of your home (location could be a huge predictor of a coaching session, too, so combine it up!), however at first, at all times have the jar very shut.
  4. Progressively cut back the variety of treats you have got in your individual. Should you constantly get treats from the jar, carrying meals turns into much less vital. Work your method in steps to an empty, clear deal with pouch, then no pouch. Identical with pockets: work towards empty pockets in freshly washed garments. After all, canines can odor meals on garments which were washed, however they’ll additionally inform the distinction between contemporary, current meals and the meals molecules that stay after washing.
  5. When your canine responds reliably to your cues if you end up not carrying meals, begin to transfer farther away from the jar earlier than you cue a conduct. The canine nonetheless has a visual “meals cue” within the image, so we need to take away that one, too. So begin getting away. Three steps. 5 steps. Do that steadily, over a number of periods. Lastly, the jar is round a nook. Or in a closed cabinet. On the different finish of the home. Simply inside your again door—and also you give the cue outdoors. Our aim is to show the canine their conduct makes meals seem, whether or not or not they see the meals beforehand.

You may even get fancy and make it so your canine normally will get a higher reinforcer once you aren’t carrying meals.

After the steps above, you are able to do most of your coaching periods such as you at all times have. However take heed to your mechanics. And make sure to maintain mixing in “distant” treats to maintain your canine believing that meals cam come from wherever.. You’ll discover it helpful to proceed to have little caches of meals round the home.

Observe: This Is Not the Time To “Fade” Treats!

Even in case you plan to go to thinner reinforcement schedules and never give your canine a deal with after every appropriate conduct, you must proceed to try this whereas doing the above process. If “previewing” meals has unintentionally turn out to be a part of the cue for all behaviors, this can be a coaching mechanics error. It’s not a reinforcement schedule problem. Repair your mechanics first. Cleansing up your antecedent association (meals being too distinguished earlier than the conduct) is separate from thinning a reinforcement schedule (how usually meals is delivered after the conduct).

You may take a look at these two posts on reinforcement schedules.

Excessive-Worth Dry Meals

A tannish-yellow ceramic treat jar that has the word "WILD" scored into the clay and painted in black
Ceramic deal with jar

Listed below are among the meals I exploit in jars round the home. They’re chosen so I don’t have to fret about spoilage.

  • Dehydrated lamb or beef lung
  • K9 Granola Manufacturing facility treats
  • American Journey Oven Baked Canine Treats
  • Stella and Chewy’s dehydrated uncooked meals
  • Lotus oven baked dry meals

I additionally use another meals with a shorter shelf life for high-value treats. I ensure that to not depart them out too lengthy.

Credit score for This Thought

Leaving meals in containers round the home isn’t a brand new or unusual concept! Neither is the above technique for educating a canine that meals can seem from a number of sources. I first learn of this apply in two completely different locations: within the previous ClickerSolutions Yahoo group, I imagine posted by Greta Kaplan, and in Sue Ailsby’s Coaching Ranges. It’s not anyone’s distinctive system, although. It follows the ideas of graduated change, stimulus management, and generalization in conduct science.

Associated Posts

Copyright 2024 Eileen Anderson

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *