Dot and Bubble brings Black Mirror-style social commentary to Physician Who with thought-provoking outcomes – Evaluate


There may be one key factor that you must find out about this week’s Physician Who: the titular character isn’t in it very a lot.

Yep, that’s proper – it’s one other ‘Physician Lite’ episode, of a form. However the place final week’s glorious 73 Yards was extra within the vein of 2008’s ‘Flip Left’, the place the present’s co-star takes the reins for an unbelievable showcase of their prowess, that is extra within the vein of one of the vital well-known Physician Who episodes of all of them – 2007’s ‘Blink’.

With fifteenth Physician Ncuti Gatwa’s Physician Who filming schedule overlapping together with his remaining work on Netflix’s Intercourse Training, these types of episodes have been in the end a necessity of manufacturing – however typically that want creates one thing stunning. Stress makes diamonds, because the saying goes.

Dot and Bubble isn’t any 73 Yards, although. It’s definitely no Blink. However the way in which it toys with the template that episode set for an episode low on the Physician is fascinating, thrilling, and impressive.

Mainly, each The Physician and companion Ruby Sunday spend nearly all of this episode on video screens, interacting with the characters of a world that we get to know for the very first time inside the confines of this episode’s run time.


Picture credit score: Lindy, performed by Callie Cooke // Credit score: BBC Studios/Dangerous Wolf/James Pardon

The world of Finetime is a vibrant, vibrant place the place every thing is okay – thus the identify. Besides, after all, that is Physician Who. Every thing is not advantageous. The subject material is outright bleak, in actual fact – and comparisons made within the run as much as airing between this and an episode of Black Mirror are certain to persist after the episode is launched.

The lead of the episode is the sickly-sweet Lindy Pepper-Bean, one of many denizens of Finetime. Callie Cooke does a superb job of bringing Lindy to life, instilling her with a way of likeability regardless of being the relentlessly egocentric common citizen of a self-absorbed nation metropolis full of people that reside and breathe their social media. It’s troublesome to make a personality like this work as a lead, however Cooke pulls it off.

The bubble of the title refers to a couple issues within the story each corporeal and metaphorical, just like the Simpsons Film model dome that retains Finetime secure from the skin world, or the globe-like ‘bubble’ that surrounds one’s head after they’re accessing their social media interface. However greater than something it refers to Lindy’s ‘social bubble’, the friendship group and nice huge video name that The Physician and Ruby in the end invade looking for solutions as to why the folks of this world are disappearing. That is Physician Who, so there’s monsters – however there’s extra to what’s happening than first meets the attention.

Watch on YouTube

Whereas 73 Yards was author Russell T Davies masterfully stretching one eerie concept to its limits, Dot and Bubble is him spinning many plates without delay. The result’s an episode that feels somewhat muddled by comparability. At worst, it even feels somewhat clunky. Given we barely know Gatwa’s Physician at this level, it’s straightforward to mourn how he solely seems on a video display screen for a lot of the episode, even when (not like final week) he does have loads of dialogue and a powerful presence all through.

The episode’s themes and commentary, which I will not get into right here for spoiler causes, deserves a lot dialogue. The ultimate stretch drives the episode’s concepts residence powerfully, as we see The Physician encounter one thing he actually by no means has earlier than. It appears like a watershed second for this incarnation of the character. It is a robust finale to an episode that absolutely carries messages and themes as delicate as a sledgehammer – however it’s in that supply that Dot & Bubble most keenly works.

As a standard-issue Physician Who journey it is rather less robust – one thing that continues the theme of this season struggling to supply up pretty commonplace belt-and-braces romps. In previous collection’ episodes like that have been regarded as ‘filler’, however that filler allowed the stuff like 73 Yards and Dot and Bubble to sing. On this new period, with its decrease episode rely, the ‘alien of the week’ filler is missed. With Dot and Bubble, what we get as an alternative is idea-rich, if flawed – however I count on within the years to come back it’s going to come to be regarded with an rising fan appreciation.



Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *