In September of 2017, Puerto Rico was hit by two highly effective hurricanes: it was grazed by Irma after which clobbered by Maria, a Class 4 storm that reduce a devastating swath throughout the island. The human and financial penalties had been dramatic and persistent.
These hurricanes prompted a private curiosity within the impression of hurricanes on birds, so I did some analysis, which finally led to an article within the April 2018 subject of Birding journal.
Broadly talking, most birds seem to outlive the preliminary “direct” results (e.g., excessive winds, rain, landslides, and flooding) of hurricanes, however are considerably impacted by the “oblique” results (e.g., lack of meals provides and roosting websites).
Instantly after hurricanes, surviving birds seem to wander in an effort to search out any remaining meals provides and appropriate habitat. Birds that depend on a closed cover, mature timber, or nectar, fruits, or seeds could wrestle to outlive. For instance, hummingbirds should discover patches the place there are nonetheless flowers. Species with small ranges (e.g., single island endemics) or tiny populations (e.g., endangered species) are particularly weak.
However because the months move, forests and different habitats regenerate and lots of birds return. Over the long run, forests mature, closing hurricane-created gaps within the cover, a minimum of till the inevitable subsequent hurricane.
Learning the impression of hurricanes requires knowledge from earlier than and after the occasion. Nevertheless, there are few long-term avian research within the Caribbean. A lot of what exists is from Puerto Rico, a U.S. territory the place researchers have quite a few ongoing investigations, together with many research in El Yunque Nationwide Forest.
Christmas Chook Counts administered by the Nationwide Audubon Society are one supply of information. CBCs have been carried out for years in a number of areas in Puerto Rico, using constant procedures that may present comparable “earlier than” and “after” knowledge.
The Fajardo CBC has been carried out since 1994. Fajardo is within the northeastern nook of Puerto Rico and the depend space contains components of El Yunque. There have been six counts since Maria: (1) December 17, 2017; (2) December 16, 2018; (3) December 15, 2019; (4) December 21, 2020; (5) and December 19, 2021; and (6) December 18, 2022.
The 2017 Depend
The 2017 CBC was carried out just some months after Maria and forests had been nonetheless extensively defoliated, with numerous felled timber and snapped branches. Some vegetation had began to re-sprout, however restoration was within the very early levels. Nonetheless, the 2017 CBC tallied 1,934 birds of 82 species, each of which had been low counts for previous CBCs (e.g., the 2016 CBC had 2,579 birds, 97 species).
When corrected for search effort within the area, participant teams discovered 1.8 species per social gathering hour, a worth not a lot decrease than the imply for counts of the earlier 10 years and throughout the vary of earlier counts (1.8-2.2). Nevertheless, they discovered solely 43 particular person birds per hour, nicely beneath the 10-year imply of 59.6, in addition to beneath the 10-year vary (47.7-68.2).
Some species skilled dramatic declines. For instance, nectarivores (e.g., hummingbirds and Bananaquits) confirmed a big drop, which was not shocking given the lack of flowers to excessive winds. Most shorebird species fell too. Surprisingly, nevertheless, a number of really elevated, together with Scaly-naped Pigeon, Crimson-legged Thrush, Puerto Rican Oriole, and Puerto Rican Tody. Others had been primarily unchanged.
The causes of those inconsistent outcomes are unclear. Some birds could have needed to forage extra actively, inflicting them to be noticed extra steadily, even when there have been fewer of them. And post-hurricane habitats themselves could result in elevated detection, as there aren’t any leaves to obscure the birds. Furthermore, as a result of many areas lacked a cover altogether, birds that usually spend time excessive in timber are compelled to floor stage, the place they’re extra prone to be noticed. And quite a few birds could cluster round remaining meals sources (e.g., Royal Palms for frugivores), rising the chance of detection.
General, post-hurricane CBC observers noticed species at a price barely decrease than earlier counts, however far fewer birds total.
The 2018 Depend
By the 2018 CBC, though there have been nonetheless apparent indicators of structural harm within the forests, most foliage had returned. However there have been nonetheless massive gaps in tree canopies that had been closed earlier than the hurricanes.
The 2018 CBC tallied 2,492 birds of 87 species. Each numbers had been larger than 2017, however nonetheless comparatively low in comparison with pre-hurricane counts. When corrected for search effort, participant teams discovered 2.0 species per social gathering hour, throughout the vary of earlier counts (1.8-2.2). They discovered 57 particular person birds per hour, according to the 10-year imply (59.6) and throughout the 10-year vary (47.7-68.2). There have been some exceptions. For instance, most nectivore numbers continued to be low.
Thus, the 2018 CBC instructed that chicken populations throughout the depend space had been steadily returning to pre-hurricane ranges. Certainly, the 2018 depend even added two new species: Black-throated Inexperienced Warbler and Higher Flamingo.
The 2019 Depend
In 2019, there was nonetheless structural harm within the forests, however most foliage had returned. Many cover gaps continued, and saplings, vines, and ferns flourished in these openings.
The 2019 CBC tallied 2,308 birds of 90 species, just like 2018. When corrected for search effort, 2.3 species per social gathering hour had been detected, which was on the excessive finish of the 10-year vary (1.8-2.3). Individuals discovered 58 particular person birds per hour, according to the historic imply (59.6) and throughout the historic vary (47.7-68.2).
Nectivores continued their sluggish restoration, apart from the Bananaquit, which had now totally rebounded, seemingly as a consequence of its excessive reproductive charges. Hummingbird numbers had been nonetheless low in comparison with historic numbers. Though there have been variations amongst species, seed-eating finch counts had been nonetheless low, however dove numbers had been just like baseline ranges. Insectivores had been on the low finish of the historic ranges, omnivores had been throughout the vary, and raptors had been beneath after returning the baseline in 2018. Waterbirds and shorebirds had been usually throughout the historic vary.
Thus, total the 2019 knowledge confirmed persevering with avian inhabitants restoration, with many species returning to pre-hurricane baseline ranges, albeit with some exceptions (e.g., Antillean Crested Hummingbird, Inexperienced-throated Carib, and Ruddy Quail-Dove).
The 2020 Depend
Regardless of the COVID-19 pandemic, the 2020 CBC was carried out (according to CDC security pointers) on December 21, 2020. A diminished variety of individuals tallied 2,335 birds of 93 species. Each numbers had been larger than 2019, however decrease than the pre-hurricane common.
When corrected for search effort, 2.3 species per social gathering hour had been detected, which was the identical as 2019 and on the excessive finish of the 10-year vary. Individuals discovered 58.7 particular person birds per hour, just like 2019, and according to the historic imply and throughout the historic vary.
General, it seems that most species have recovered to pre-hurricane ranges, with a number of lingering exceptions, together with hummingbirds. Most hummingbird species had been nonetheless detected at diminished charges (e.g., Antillean Crested Hummingbird, Inexperienced-throated Carib, Inexperienced Mango, and Antillean Mango), although one species (Puerto Rican Emerald) has bounced again to pre-hurricane ranges. That is according to previous research which have constantly documented post-hurricane declines in nectivores.
The remaining species at diminished ranges are usually fruit and seed eaters, together with Antillean Euphonia. Some insectivores stay at elevated ranges, together with Puerto Rican Woodpecker and Puerto Rican Tody, although a number of (e.g., Grey Kingbird) have nonetheless not recovered. Ruddy Quail-Dove had been noticed for the primary time since 2017. And the numerous species that had already returned to pre-hurricane ranges usually continued at these ranges.
Thus, the 2020 knowledge point out that almost all species have returned to pre-hurricane ranges, with a number of remaining exceptions. There seems to be appreciable resiliency within the populations of Puerto Rican birds. The following depend is scheduled for December 19, 2021.
The 2021 Depend
For the second consecutive yr, COVID-19 impacted the depend, with fewer individuals and fewer areas lined. Furthermore, rain and wind on depend day hindered proceedings. Nonetheless, a diminished variety of individuals tallied 2,013 birds of 80 species. Each numbers had been decrease than 2020, and decrease than the pre-hurricane averages. Individuals noticed 1.98 species per social gathering hour, which was inside, however on the low finish of, the pre-Maria vary. They noticed 54.3 particular person birds per social gathering hour, which was additionally throughout the ten-year vary.
Most species have returned to pre-hurricane ranges, although there are a number of exceptions, a few of that are seemingly defined by the diminished variety of observers and protection. That stated, a number of hummingbird species and egrets and herons proceed to be seen at decrease ranges. Though the pandemic and climate issues make comparisons tough, it seems that the chicken neighborhood throughout the depend space has confirmed extremely resilient to the 2017 hurricanes. Certainly, a brand new species (Limpkin) was added in 2021.
The 2022 Depend
For the primary time for the reason that pandemic, COVID-19 didn’t impression the depend, which had quite a few individuals and good climate. Individuals tallied 2,499 birds of 98 species. Each numbers had been similar to the pre-hurricane averages. Individuals noticed 2.2 species per social gathering hour, which was on the excessive finish of the pre-Maria vary. They noticed 58 particular person birds per social gathering hour, which was in the course of the pre-hurricane vary. A brand new species (Wooden Duck) was noticed.
Most species have returned to pre-hurricane ranges, with a number of notable exceptions, together with a number of hummingbird species. No pre-hurricane native species has been misplaced from the depend space and and a few have seen substantial will increase relative to their pre-hurricane ranges. The frequent Bananaquit, a nectivore, is considerably above its pre-Maria ranges, seemingly as a consequence of its excessive reproductive charges, significantly in comparison with the hummingbird species that haven’t reached pre-Maria ranges. The 2017 hurricanes opened forest canopies, seemingly rising flower and fruit manufacturing, and lots of of their related birds have elevated. The frugivorous Scaly-naped Pigeon had a file depend in 2022, for instance.
As with the 2020 and 2021 counts, the 2022 depend reinforces the conclusion that the chicken neighborhood within the depend space is extremely resilient.
* * * * *
Though six years of information from a single CBC supplies solely a sliver of the general image, the inhabitants traits proceed to be optimistic. Furthermore, the restoration seems to be according to these of earlier well-documented hurricanes, corresponding to Hugo in 1989. The post-hurricane knowledge inform a narrative of avian resilience.
Scientists proceed to review the impression of Irma and Maria, which can enhance our understanding of the impression of hurricanes on Caribbean birds. Amongst different issues, biologists have decided that the impression of Maria on timber was far more important than prior storms, seemingly as a consequence of local weather change.
* * * * *
As soon as once more, heartfelt due to Dr. Joseph M. Wunderle Jr., who wrote a variety of the key scientific papers that shaped the idea of my Birding article. Now retired, Dr. Wunderle was a scientist on the Worldwide Institute of Tropical Forestry (IITF), part of the U.S. Forest Service. He’s additionally a founding member of BirdsCaribbean and the editor-in-chief of the Journal of Caribbean Ornithology. Dr. Wunderle is the compiler for the Fajardo CBC and graciously offered the information described above.
This put up was initially revealed on January 8, 2019, and was up to date on January 14, 2020, January 15, 2021, and January 6, 2022.
Photograph: Bananaquit, Pearly-eyed Thrasher, and Inexperienced-throated Carib by Jason Crotty; Birding by American Birding Affiliation.